Paulson's Crash

US Treasury Secretary Seriously Messes Up

Blaming Friday's mini crash on the 20th anniversary of the 1987 stock market collapse and a few earnings misses is not even close to being on target.

The blame for Friday's collapse can be squarely placed on the shoulders of US Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson. Paulson hosted his G-7 contemporaries last week in Washington to discuss exchange rates and other policies, however, while publicly stating the US supports a strong dollar, there did not appear to be much conviction behind his statements. Word has it, the US did little to support a reversal in the weak dollar--particularly against the euro--and this left the other treasury secretaries not very happy. Rather than direct their statements of rejection at the US, they chose to blame China instead with further calls for yuan appreciation. As the news leaked out, the US market began to tank.

Paulson's move not to support a reversal of the US dollar against the euro follows the formation of the SIV fund to provide financial support for off-balance sheet debt held by the major money-center banks. SIVs are not very different from what Enron did and in certain ways is worse since these institutions have decades of experience at knowing what is and what is not on- or off-balance sheet financing. Paulson still has not clearly detailed the reasoning behind the move.

Mr. Paulson also had few good things to say about housing this week. While many of the seeds for the housing collapse were put in place prior to his tenure at the Treasury, why he felt the need to remind the markets of what it already knows, leaves one to ponder. Paulson was pretty much stating the obvious.

Friday's stock market mini-crash should be called Paulson's Crash. He is bailing out his pals on Wall Street with the SIVs fund and he will not help the Europeans get out of their difficult position of too strong of a currency who now have decided to turn their blame for the US' incompetence to China. Forcing appreciation of the yuan when Chinese officials are working very hard to slowdown their economy and stop their run away stock market is a recipe for disaster and unfair for the Chinese. As the yuan appreciates, this will only bring more money into China and drive an overly inflated stock market even higher.

Paulson falls into a long line of Bush Administration appointees who are charismatic, are excellent at articulating a thought and are willing to express their views to the world. However, there is only one problem--whether it is Cheney, Rumsfeld, Wolfowitz or Paulson--it is that they are always wrong.

Unlike Rubin and Corzine, former Goldman Sachs partners who have demonstrated some serious success after leaving the investment firm, it looks like Paulson is not following the same path.